When the Waters Came (A Day to Remember) (2024)

1899 Johnstown, Pennsylvania

What a horrific event! On May 31, 1899, a dam broke and flooded Johnstown. More than 2,000 people lost their lives.

The novel is not so much about the event itself, but the aftermath. How does one pick up the pieces of wreckage: emotional and physical. With devastation everywhere, it's hard to know where to begin.

Lots of historical details included in the pages, such as the inclusion of Clara Barton and the Red Cross helping in Johnstown. Wrapped around all the historical detail is a message of hope and a budding romance.

My gratitude to the author for a complimentary copy of the novel. I was not required to post a review and all opinions expressed are my own.

I found myself enraptured by a narrative that transcends conventional storytelling, reaching profound depths that elevate it beyond the ordinary. Deserving more than a mere five stars, this novel masterfully weaves a tapestry of faith, resilience, and societal reflection against the haunting backdrop of Johnstown, Pennsylvania. For aficionados of Christian historical fiction and romance, this book is an absolute gem that I wholeheartedly recommend.

Pastor Monty, tending to his flock, harbors a fervent desire for divine intervention amidst the luxury of Lake Conemaugh. The haunting specter of his own privileged past in Pittsburgh society adds complexity to his journey. A flood of historical significance serves as the backdrop for a story that unfolds with a compelling mix of urgency and grace.

The story shifts seamlessly to Annamae Worthington, whose prompt response to the aftermath of the Johnstown flood contrasts with the delayed arrival of the Red Cross. Intertwined with the resurgence of typhoid fever, her journey introduces layers of tragedy and emotional complexity. Amid receding waters, Monty's faltering faith experiences renewal through collaborative efforts with Annamae, fostering a profound connection.

Candice Sue Patterson’s craftsmanship shines as the story explores the aftermath of calamity, encompassing the distribution of supplies, care for orphans, and the collective efforts to rebuild shattered lives. The burgeoning kinship between Monty and Annamae serves as a poignant focal point, a testimony to the resilience of the human spirit in the face of adversity.

As the story continues to develop, readers are swept into the heart of life-changing turmoil. The narrative skillfully navigates the shadows of the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club, revealing a tapestry of secrets that loom ominously, jeopardizing the delicate connection between Monty and Annamae.

The gifted author skillfully weaves historical events with authentic Christian faith, drawing readers into a realm where faith is tested, resilience takes root, and the subtle intricacies of the human spirit are explored with a tapestry woven with love, compassion, and forgiveness.

I was blessed to receive an eARC of When the Waters Came from Barbour Fiction publishers through NetGalley. It's important to note that I neither had an obligation to craft a favorable review nor received any compensation for my words. These sentiments genuinely reflect my heartfelt assessment and the profound impact this exceptional novel has had on me.

I love historical fiction as they are, but the fact that this was inspired by such true events made this an incredible read. What a brilliant way to fictionalize a true event of the Johnstown flood. I thought this story was so interesting, and I appreciated the way Candice Sue Patterson talks about all of the true occurrences and creates some of the characters to give the story depth and to make it her own.

4.5 ⭐️ I have been fascinated with the Johnstown flood ever since reading David McCullough’s book many years ago. This novel is a great account of the events and does well to wrestle through grief and forgiveness from a Biblical godly perspective. There were a few things I would have changed but overall it was a very good story.

A Gripping Tale of Resilience and Redemption!

I recently had the pleasure of discovering the writing talent of Candice Sue Patterson through her most recent novel, "When the Waters Came."

Patterson takes the reader on a journey leading up to the Johnstown Flood of 1889 and into the heart of the disaster, immersing them in the harrowing aftermath of a dam break.

The story unfolds through the perspectives of two compelling characters: Monty, the resilient town pastor who miraculously survives the flood, and Annamae, a dedicated nurse with the newly formed Red Cross. The intricate weaving of their experiences adds depth to the narrative and keeps readers engaged from start to finish.

Monty's struggle with wavering faith in the wake of the catastrophic event is both poignant and relatable. His efforts to conceal his connection to wealthy figures held responsible for the dam's neglect add a layer of suspense and intrigue.

Annamae's journey is equally compelling, as she grapples with forgiveness amid her personal vendetta against the wealthy responsible for her father's demise. The interplay between her determination for justice and the developing romantic involvement with Monty adds a great dynamic to the narrative.

The novel skillfully explores themes of faith, resilience, and redemption. Patterson masterfully navigates Monty's internal struggles and Annamae's quest for justice, creating a narrative that is uplifting.

"When the Waters Came" is not just a historical drama—it's a testament to the human spirit's capacity to overcome adversity. Patterson's storytelling prowess and the depth of the characters make this book a standout in its genre. I highly recommend it to anyone seeking a riveting tale of faith, forgiveness, and the enduring power of the human soul. A true five-star masterpiece!

Thank you to NetGalley, the author, and publisher for the opportunity to review this novel. I was not required to write a positive review, and all opinions are my own.

This tragic story based on true historical events was delivered in a way which made me feel the loss and heartache and struggle of the survivors to start fresh.

The story was rich with historical facts between the fictional story developing between Monty and Annamae.

The lesson of forgiveness and how you can only truly moved on when you let go of anger and bitterness came across strong.

*I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. All opinions expressed are my own.*

Gut-wrenching and soul-searching! It's only mid-January but I've just found my first favorite book of 2024! I started reading "When the Waters Came" during a rainstorm, so I was immediately caught up in the vivid descriptions of torrential rain, rushing flood waters, and human suffering beyond imagination. Author Candice Sue Patterson blends fictional characters and real people to share her story of the devastating Johnstown Flood of 1889, and the results are mesmerizing!
.
When the Waters Came is a captivating story that's rich in historical details, raw emotions, and resiliency that springs from hope, faith, and trust in God. I recommend this inspirational page-turner to all who enjoy historical Christian fiction.

I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. There was no obligation for a positive review. These are my own opinions.

When the Waters Came
by Candice Sue Patterson
Publisher: Barbour Publishing
Series: A Day to Remember, Book 1
Rated: 5
Obtain: Borrow or buy
Back of the Book: “An act of greed or an act of God?
Introducing a new series of 6 exciting novels featuring historic American disasters that transformed landscapes and multiple lives. Whether by nature or by man, these disasters changed history and were a day to be remembered.
Pastor Montgomery Childs has tended his flock in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, for two years. While his pews are full every Sunday, he most desires to see a reckoning between God and the kings of industry who recreate on Lake Conemaugh. The pleasure grounds, flowing alcohol, and business dealings of the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club taunts Monty as he works to heal the wounds inflicted from his own privileged childhood among Pittsburgh society. Like Noah, Monty prays against the evil surrounding him, but he never expects God to send a flood.
It takes five days for the Red Cross to respond to the Johnstown flood disaster, but when it does, Annamae Worthington is ready to help. Apprenticing under Clara Barton has prepared her for the job, but nothing can prepare her for the death and destruction that awaits. As if the survivors haven’t suffered enough, typhoid fever ravages the town, resurfacing suppressed emotions regarding her father’s death.
Narrowly surviving the flood and the horrifying things he’s witnessed, Monty’s faith is floundering. Then a Red Cross nurse puts him to work helping with the typhoid fever victims arriving at the hospital tents every hour. Monty and Annamae work together distributing disinfectants and supplies, housing orphans, and serving those left behind. Slowly, his faith resurfaces. A kinship forms between them neither can ignore. But when an investigation into the collapsed dam points to the South Fork Hunting and Fishing Club, secrets emerge that may tear them apart.”

Impressions: I loved this book. On a personal note, I was born in Conemaugh Hospital and have family that have lived in Johnstown since the flood, making this story special to me. I think the history of the flood is so interesting. The author incorporated so many details, bringing this story to life. It was without question an emotionally sobering time for the people of Johnstown and the surrounding area, and I feel like the author did a wonderful job exploring the response of all involved. The main characters were perfectly suited to the fictional aspects of this story. I appreciated the different perspectives of people who were part of Johnstown during this time of history. A little history and a little love made this engaging story a must-read.

Quotes: “All a body can do is focus on what can be accomplished each day. Take care physically and spiritually so one can be of service to others. And most importantly, remember who holds the entire world in His hands.’”

“‘The beauty of being set free from bondage is that we don’t have to let the anger and bitterness of our pasts hold us back anymore. We can drop the chains and walk away.’”

I received an ARC of this book via the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review shared here.

This story takes place in Johnstown Philadelphia in 1889, it made me think of Hurricane Katrina, which devastated three states in 2005. The levees surrounding the city of New Orleans had engineering defects that exacerbated the issue. Likewise his tale based on true events, revealed that the South Fork Fishing and Hunting Club was aware of the dam's cracks but took no action to stop and /or prevent this tragedy.

Not only was this community trying to pick up the pieces of their lives after a devastating loss of life, loved ones, and mass destruction, but they were also battling typhoid fever.
I enjoyed how the author used the perspectives of Pastor Monty and volunteer nurse Annamae Worthington to tell this story. Annamae is a nurse who is working under Miss Clara Barton, (who founded the American Red Cross.) It was fun to learn that not only was Clara a hospital nurse in the Civil War, but she was a teacher, a patent clerk and mentor to Annamae.

The investigation into why the dam broke, which Monty and Annamae collaborated on, unfortunately points to Monty's uncle, whom Annamae believes is to blame for her father's passing. It's possible that this will be the last straw for their newly discovered love.

Even though the subject matter in this book was difficult to read at times, I couldn't put it down. As the main characters start a new chapter in their lives, the author provides them with hope. Each learns how to let go and deal with life's challenges, allowing God to heal their bodies and wounded hearts.

Disclosure of Material Connection: I requested and received a copy of this book by the publisher and NetGalley. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255 “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsem*nts and Testimonials in Advertising.”

Nora St. Laurent
TBCN Where Book Fun Begins!
The Book Club Network blog https://psalm516.blogspot.com/

The well-written account immediately drew me in as we witness the impending Johnstown flood from a young pastor’s eyewitness experience. It feels like you are present with those suffering during this horrific devastation. Then the ongoing aftermath unfolds, with its troubles, trials, and trauma, and even a love relationship blossoming amid the devastating tragedy. The compelling plot with its twists and surprises and the authentic characters portrayed bring this fictional retelling of a terrible disaster from US history to life and grab the emotions in the process. The author did a great job presenting a believable and gripping piece that remains in your mind long after reading the story. Could such widespread destruction have been avoided? Actual people are named in the tale, like Nurse Clara Barton of the Red Cross, along with the rich men who refused to consider trying to prevent the impending danger. I received a copy from the publisher to review. All opinions are my own. #WhentheWatersCame #NetGalley

When the Waters Came kicks off a new historical fiction series from Christian publishing house, Barbour. If the rest of the series is anything like this first installment, readers are in for a treat!

This book recounts the tragedy of the Johnstown flood in the 1800s. While I had heard of this event, I didn’t know much about it, so I was immediately engaged in the historical facts of the book. I also greatly enjoyed the character development of Annamae and Monty. Each had his/her own well-developed storyline and their interactions with each other felt natural, not forced. The faith element in this book was just right--naturally occurring and realistic, not forced or preachy.

Thanks go to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.

I loved this book. It is a sad part of history. And my heart ached while reading it. The author did a great job without being too graphic with the details. It is a great romance novel as well.
My favorite quote from the book “ Everyone sins nailed Jesus to the cross. He wrote each of our names in his wounds. Even the ones of those he knew would never ask for forgiveness. That way, everyone would have a fair chance of Heaven. If they chose to accept him, Heforgave out of love.” His words pricked her heart. “ I’m not Jesus, she whispered, more tears spilling down her cheeks. “ I don’t love those men like he does. “ Monty reached for her hand, holding it tenderly bewteen his. “ None of us love like Jesus. But it’s something we should constantly strive for.”
If you like history and romance in a fictional novel then you need to pick up a copy of this book and read it for yourself.

I received a Complimentary copy from the author and Celebrate Lit and these opinions are my own.

When a flood of horrific proportions devastates the town of Johnstown, Pennsylvania, Red Cross and other volunteers descend into the valley to tend to the survivors and clean up the debris.
Ms. Patterson recounts the true, harrowing experiences in a way that tugs at your heart. The first few chapters describe the onslaught of water and show the bravery of the few that made it out alive. In subsequent chapters, she chronicles the extensive job it was to clean up and start to repair the damage and to house the survivors. Based on a real event, the author used extensive research to make the story come alive, including quotes from contemporary sources. She interestingly includes notable dignitaries and Ckara Barton, the head of the newly formed Red Cross.
The fictional pastor, Monty and red Cross nurse, Annamae, were very realistic, as were their struggles. This book had many lessons to teach about perseverance, compassion and forgiveness, the formost beig forgiveness. How can we not forgive when Jesus has forgiven all sinners, even the ones who do not accept His great sacrifice. Forgiveness benefits the one who forgives even if the one who is forgiven doesn’t acknowledge it.
This is my first read of 2024 and it will be on my favorites list for the year.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author. I was not required to post a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*

What a book! So heart-wrenching, I never knew this event in history took place! The author does a wonderful job weaving history and fiction together, using real accounts as a basis for this story. I cannot even imagine the horrors those poor people faced. Highly recommend for a quick, engaging read.

I voluntarily read an advanced copy of this book. I am not required to leave a review. The comments and opinions expressed are strictly my own.

I love historical fiction, but most focus on very well known events like WWII. This was unique, well-written, and a great look at God’s love through the lens of disaster.

“When the Waters Came,” the first book in the A Day to Remember series, is a captivating journey through historical tragedy and triumph. The book, centered around the 1889 flooding of Johnstown, immediately grabs attention with its alluring cover art and a poignant opening line that sets a haunting tone.

The story sheds light on a significant historical event filled with genuine emotion.
The writing is not only evocative but also nicely paced. The characters, particularly Monty and Annamea, are authentic and relatable, making it easy to empathize with their struggles and root for their faith.

This book is a beautifully displayed triumph over tragedy story, blending historical accuracy, engaging characters, and themes of faith, forgiveness, and fortitude.

First Line: Fog suspended from hemlock and spruce in a ghostly blanket that whispered along the peaks of decorated headstones, and the mourners gathered round.
Series: A Day to Remember, book 1
Genre: Christian Historical Fiction
Author: Candice Sue Patterson
Page Count: 256

#CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions are 100% mine.

3.5⭐️
Well written and the first 50% was very interesting as I'd never heard of this disaster, however when it was obvious that the story was headed towards being of the romance genre I lost a lot of interest✋️
Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the advanced copy of this novel

When the Waters Came is from (new to me) author Candice sue Patterson. it is the first book in a series focused on great natural disaster events in american history. This book focuses on the Johnstown Flood of 1889.

Unlike many other books, this book begins moments before the dam breaks and focuses on what happens during the flood and in the days and weeks after the flood. This is a different take from most books I've read.

the reader experiences the flood from two perspectives:

Monty--the town pastor who survives the flood only because his house got stuck next to the church and he was able to climb to the roof and then into the church attic.

Annamae--a nurse with the newly formed Red Cross who arrives with Clara Barton 5 days after the flood to take care of the people

Annamae finds Monty wandering and brings him to get help at the tent and thus begins their friendship.

Thru the book, Monty deals with wavering faith in God after such a horrific disaster as well as trying to hide his connection to the wealthy men the towns holds at fault for not taking care of the dam. What would they do to learn he was one of the men's nephews and grew up in wealth? But he's also determined to follow the investigation. His past life is revealed just in moments he shares with Annamae or inward reflection.

Annamae's journey through teh book is one of learning to forgive in order to release her bitterness. She lost her father due to the greed of a wealthy businessman and she wants them to pay. And this disaster just fuels her hatred and bitterness--they just CAN'T get off scott free again from taking responsibility. She will do whatever it takes to get them to pay...even if it means telling Monty's secret to the press.

MOnty has to learn how to put aside his love for Annamae in order to help her spiritual journey--and at the same time he has to learn to find strength in his own faith to be able to help others again. How can He share that God is still good after a disaster of godly proportion?

If you have never read anything about the Johnstown flood, I think this book will whet your whistle for more. I have read a lot about it after I first encountered it in the book by Catherine Marshall "Julie". And I love learning more and more about it. Even though it makes you get angry at the Robber Barons of the age.

I will be following this series because it's the type that I enjoy reading.

4 Stars. Very detailed and had a good plot that wasn't always predictable.

**I received this as an ARC copy from the publishers and NetGalley. I wasn't required to write a positive review and all my opinions are my own.

In the realm of Christian Historical Romance, a new gem has emerged that captivates readers with its powerful narrative and dynamic storytelling. “When the Waters Came” by Candice Sue Patterson is not just a love story but a poignant exploration of faith, resilience, and service against the backdrop of natural disasters that transformed the American landscape and countless lives.

Pastor Montgomery Childs, also known as Monty, is at the novel’s heart, a character whose unwavering faith in God and dedication to service set the tone for the entire narrative. As readers embark on this literary journey, they witness Monty’s resilience and willingness to serve, which adds depth to the character and as a source of inspiration.

Annamae Worthington’s involvement in the Red Cross alongside the legendary Clara Barton adds an intriguing dimension to the story. This historical context enriches the narrative, providing readers with a glimpse into the challenges faced by individuals serving during times of disaster. Annamae’s character serves as a reminder of the unsung heroes who played pivotal roles in alleviating the suffering caused by natural calamities.

One cannot ignore the vivid imagery and attention to detail that Candice Sue Patterson brings to the pages of “When the Waters Came.” However, it’s crucial to note that the book may not be suited for all readers, as it delves into the harsh realities of the disaster. The author’s commitment to portraying the events with realism contributes to the book’s power and makes it compelling.

In a genre that often intertwines love, faith, and history, “When the Waters Came” stands out as a testament to the strength of the human spirit in the face of adversity. Candice Sue Patterson skillfully weaves together a narrative that entertains and resonates with readers on a deeper level. If you’re searching for a Christian Historical Romance that goes beyond the ordinary, inviting you to reflect on the power of faith and love, “When the Waters Came” deserves a spot on your reading list.

So, embark on this literary journey and discover a story that will linger in your heart long after you’ve turned the last page. Be sure to check out When the Waters Came by Candice Sue Patterson for yourself. I know I am looking forward to reading more books in this series.

I received a complimentary copy of this book, but this in no way influenced my review. All opinions are my own.

I listened to the first part of McCullogh’s story of the Johnstown flood but never finished it. It was such a disastrous happening and possibly could have been prevented.

This story of the event made me feel like I was there, experiencing the horrors as the residents of Johnstown and nearby communities did. Told through the eyes of Monty, a local pastor who survives and Annamae, a Red Cross nurse who comes from Washington, D.C.to help. I felt I could see and hear the trauma of it all.

An interesting historical note is that Clara Barton, founder of the American Red Cross, was present in the recovery effort.

I received this book from the publisher via net galley in exchange for an honest review. Four stars!

I immensely enjoyed reading through this book based off of the historical flooding in Johnstown, PA in the late 1800s. This story has some interesting characters and has Christian views shared throughout the book. Don't let that scare you from finding out the true accounts of what happened when the South Fork Dam failed for it's residents that tragic day. Between the rich history of this story and the tragedies the people of this town went through has me wanting to learn more about that fateful day. I'm looking forward to reading some more books by this author!

*Thank you to NetGalley & Barbour Fiction for an eBook copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion/review of this book!

When The Waters Came by Candice Sue Patterson is the first book I’ve read from her. This story, taken from true events of a catastrophic flood in 1889, was so moving, so heartbreaking, so inspiring. God came through momentously for the survivors of this horrifying ordeal and Candice captured that so beautifully. This is the first of six books based from true event tragedies coming from Barbour Fiction. I hope to read each one of them!!

I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher. The opinions expressed are completely my own.

Johnstown, Pennsylvania. The year: 1889. The South Fork dam breaks resulting in the whole city being wiped out. It’s a devastating day for the town and its inhabitants. Men, women, children, animals — all helpless to escape the rushing waters. Over 2,000 people including hundreds of children are killed.

Pastor Monty Childs and Red Cross nurse Annamae Worthington meet as they work together after the Johnstown flooding that obliterated the city. As Monty ministers to the survivors that have lost family members and their homes, Annamae cares for their physical wounds and needs. There is a spark between the two that neither have experienced before but between the floods devastation and an outbreak of typhoid fever, both are extremely busy caring for others. As Annamae cares for the wounded, she discovers the flood may not be “an act of God” after all, but the result of negligence from the Hunting & Fishing Club’s wealthy and powerful men that owned the dam. This sparks her desire to see these men held responsible and justice served. Surely Pastor Monty can help her but he’s holding something back- what and why?

Wow, Candice Sue Patterson has done it again. What’s amazing about this story is that so much of it is true. The author weaves real people such as Clara Barton from the Red Cross and real quotes, events and real survivors stories into the mix which make for an emotionally charged, faith filled story. The devastation these innocent people faced was unimaginable and their stories live on throughout these pages. We see so many relatable scenarios presented such as the strong, faith-filled pastor struggling with why has God allowed this tragedy to happen? Or Annamae struggling with anger and forgiveness. These struggles were genuine and it was delicately written and presented in a way that gave God the glory, beauty from the ashes, light from darkness!

The authors note must not be missed at the end of the book. There you will read how much time and effort was put into the study for this book which as you read from start to finish is very evident. I really commend the author for doing an amazing job with the research.

Content: no language, closed door. Death and suffering are themes throughout.

When the Waters Came, the first book in Barbour’s A Day to Remember series, is a powerful, compelling story. This skillfully woven, poignant tale based on a true historical event, the 1889 Johnstown Flood, drew me in immediately and kept me immersed for the entirety of the story. The fictional characters are well-crafted and memorable. In addition, many real-life historical figures are wonderfully and believably infused into the fictional story. Rich sensory imagery and vivid, detailed descriptions of the flood and its aftermath put you at the scene allowing you to experience the story as you read. The amazing historical detail in the story reflects extensive, meticulous research. Monty and Annamae’s love story is sweet and at times bittersweet. I appreciate the strong, inspiring faith element with themes of hope, forgiveness, and restoration. This is the kind of story that stays with you long after the last word is read. I love this book and have added it to my Best Books Ever list. I recommend it as a must read for historical romance fans.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Barbour Publishing with no obligation to post a review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.

3.5 Stars
This was a Book Club selection that I wasn’t excited about reading and almost convinced myself to not read, but then I remembered I joined the Book Club so that I could be introduced to books I wouldn’t normally select. So I started it 5 days ago and instantly became interested in the characters and the plot. I thought it was a good book overall, but this isn’t a top fave for me.

This was such an enthralling story about the flooding of Johnstown. I had never heard of this tragedy and the awful circ*mstances behind it. I loved the way the author weaved in the story of Clara Barton and the Red Cross. Monty and Annamae were such fascinating characters and I enjoyed how they wrestled with their own past throughout the story.

Thanks so much to netgalley and the publisher for the arc. The opinions are my own.

Very thoroughly researched and engaging book. The author did well to merge a fictional plot with real life events. Definitely recommended, especially for historical readers.

This was an interesting book about the flood that happened in Johnstown, Pennsylvania in 1889. I had no idea that this was a part of history and so that aspect had me focused on the story at the start. I can't imagine what those people went through and this book doesn't hold back on the hard parts. It is a clean read but with such a disaster you can't avoid the hard things of death and some details. There is a bit of a love story and you really get to see into the life of Pastor Montgomery Childs. I had a difficult time really getting into the last part of the book. I hate to say it but it just didn't hold my attention. I didn't care a lot about the romance and the historical aspects were interesting but just didn't grab me at the end. I think many people will love this story but it is just okay for me. I am glad that authors are taking little known historical events and making them come alive.

Three Stars.

"I received this book from the publisher for free. All opinions are my own and I was not required to write a positive review."

This is not my first foray into reading books by Candice Sue Patterson, but I was particularly disappointed by this offering.
The plot doesn't really move until significantly deep into the book, instead it reads more like a factual retelling of the events. I truly had to fight my way through the book and not give up on it. Once I got past the retelling of events, and the plot lightened up a bit, I somewhat enjoyed it.

The book details one of the most heart-breaking disasters in United States history--the Johnstown Flood. The greed, the power, and the personal desires of those who were in control of the upkeep of the dam on the Conemaugh River was outrageous, at the least, and criminal, at most. One of the gratifying parts of the book was Clara Barton's contribution to help in the aftermath of the flood.

When the reader finally gets to it, the heart of the plot is the story of Monty and Annamae, but it is quite a slog to get to that part of the novel.

There are many characters based on real people within the pages of this novel and that brings a bit of charm to the plot. I once read a book by Catherine Marshall called, Julie, which is about the same events. I was hoping for this book to be of the same caliber. It just fell short to me.

Still, others will like it and I hope my opinion doesn't stop them from reading it. There is a lot of actual history in this book which is fascinating to read. Still, I give it three stars.

Barbour Publishing provided the copy I read for this review. All opinions expressed were solely my own.

Barbour kicks off a new series, A Day to Remember, with When the Waters Came by Candice Sue Patterson. Each historic American tragedy steals many lives and effects great changes in those left behind.

When the Waters Came recounts the chilling details of the 1889 Johnstown flood. This is a rough read, emotionally. Fortunately, I could keep reading because I knew that Patterson’s second goal, besides giving life to a horrific disaster, is to give hope.

The first sentence is forbidding and had the hackles on the back of my neck standing straight up. I was ready for the deluge of words that would describe this horrible tragedy. But, no, just as the people of Johnstown are caught unprepared, I was unprepared for the raw, gritty picture Patterson presents.

We meet Pastor Monty, who struggles to help his fellow survivors in town. Monty wants desperately to help his neighbors, but his faith is wavering amidst all the death and destruction. Plus Monty is hiding a secret that could destroy everything he has worked so hard to build.

We also meet Annamae, a nurse who accompanies Clara Barton to set up a Red Cross hospital camp and temporary residences for survivors. Annamae’s own past causes her to become very self-righteous as she seeks vengeance for those who lost their lives.

The burden of reading this story is twofold: first, I found the tragedies hard to work through, while knowing the value of understanding them. Secondly, Patterson forces the reader into both Monty and Annamae’s shoes. How would you handle their experiences that made more complex by the good they want to do and the answers they seek, plus the secrets they keep so carefully guarded? Don’t miss this chilling, but hopeful start to Barbour’s new series!

I received a copy of the book from Celebrate Lit via NetGalley, plus won a copy through GoodReads Giveaways. I also bought my own copy. No positive review was required, and all opinions are my own.

Notable Quotables:

“If every member of Johnstown, no matter their station, lined up and told their stories, the horrific tales would last for months. One thing the newspaper headlines had correct: the disaster was something ‘no pen could describe.’”

“Never take your eyes off the cross. No matter what happens in your life, you’ll always find healing at the cross.”

“My father taught me how to navigate the stars so I could always find my way home. Keep your gaze fixed upon the One who created those stars, Monty. He’ll guide you home.”

“The Lord’s words were powerful, His promises true, but one had to open their soul and allow it to soak in, to nourish, to heal. Circ*mstances such as these made trusting anything difficult.”